Jan. 2006 - you are here

CRA Home Page
About CRA
CRA Membership Application
CRA Calendar
Carmel Beach Cleanup
CRA Newsletter
CRA newsletters from 2012
CRA newsletters from 2011
CRA newsletters from 2010
CRA Newsletters from 2009
CRA News November 2008
CRA News October 2008
CRA News September 2008 - You are here
CRA News May 2008
CRA News April 2008
CRA News February 2008
CRA Newsletter January 2008
CRA Newsletters from 2007
CRA Newsletters from 2006
CRA Newsletters from 2005
CRA Newsletters from 2004
CRA Newsletters from 2003
CRA Newsletters from 2002
CRA Newsletters from 2001
CRA Newsletters from 2000
CRA Newsletters from 1999
Links to related web sites
CRA Photo Gallery
 

CRA News September 2008

Selected articles from the newsletter of the Carmel Residents Association

Susie Carr , Don Carr and Dick Laney at August barbecue
We aren't sure whether Susie Carr was describing a fish she caught or discussing the elaborate fiesta decorations with husband Don and Dick Laney. Susie and Don, long-time chairs of the twilight barbecue, co- chaired the event this year with the Jane and Tony Diamond. Dick Laney barbecued the sausage hors d’oeuvres, while his wife Frankie prepared and served the delicious Mexican beans.


CRA May General Meeting:
Joe Livernois, executive editor of The Herald
Meet the editor and hear how
The Herald will cover the election

Thursday, September 25
         4:45 p.m.
Vista Lobos Meeting Room
(Torres between 3rd & 4th)

There have been many changes at The Herald, including its purchase by Media News Group, since the paper was featured at a Carmel Residents Association meeting.

On September 25, newly-appointed executive editor Joe Livernois will speak to us about The Herald and how it will cover the upcoming election. All of the current campaigns, from President to Congress to local issues have generated an enormous amount of interest, so this should be a lively discussion. In addition, there will be plenty of time to ask questions on any subject relating to media coverage and The Herald.

Before his appointment as executive editor in May, Joe Livernois was city editor of The Herald, where he has worked for 25 years. He was hired to work the copy desk after leaving a job at the Carmel Pine Cone. "I've been a reporter, a columnist, a city editor, a bureau chief and a general nuisance during my career at The Herald," Livernois said. In addition to working for the Pine Cone, our speaker was the editor of a weekly Prunedale paper, North County News.

Joe Livernois grew up in the Imperial Valley and started in newspapers as the farm reporter for the Imperial Valley Press. He recently completed a 39-week serial in The Herald about a visit with his long-lost father. The serial, called The Road to Guanajuato, is now available in book form. For those readers who missed the serial, or enjoyed it and want to own the book, it can be ordered from Joe's web site: www.road.nivernais.com



EDITORIAL

Carmel Beach -- a jewel which needs polishing
Is it time to begin thinking about saying no to fires?

Carmel Beach, the city's crown jewel, is badly tarnished.

The main culprit is charcoal. Charcoal is everywhere -- the result of hundreds of legal fires added each year south of 10th Avenue and a significant number of illegal fires north of 10th.

An additional problem is the severe erosion at Ocean Avenue and at 8th caused by the city's failure for several years to replenish the sand by moving it uphill with a bulldozer. Money has now been budgeted for this although no action has yet been taken. (See photos on pages 5 and 8 of the printed version of the September 2008 CRA News.)

The burned-out fires, which CRA beach cleanup volunteers have tackled for 18 years, not only yield up hundreds of pounds of dirty, black charcoal each time our workers clean the beach, but also copious amounts of broken glass, beer bottles, nails and other remnants of late-night parties.

Due in large part to the efforts of CRA board member Skip Lloyd who, through persuasive words and graphic photos, has called the plight of the beach to the City Council's attention, action has been taken. The council budgeted $10,000 to hire four workers to pick up charcoal on the beach once a week during heavy-use months -- probably not enough, but it's a start.

Suggesting that the council consider whether to adopt an ordinance to ban all fires on the beach and to set up a program to clean up the existing fouling of the sand, Lloyd wrote:

"The city's master plan speaks of the pristine, white sand of the beach as a unique and important resource to be maintained. Indeed, the city's web page proudly boasts of 'a one-mile-long pure white sandy beach' as a prominent attraction of Carmel. I submit that this issue cannot be neglected any longer and must be addressed promptly. It would be tragic if our beach were permanently damaged by neglect. I am sure none of us would like to have it be said of us that we let this happen because we didn't say or do something to prevent it."

Lloyd pointed out that, at the south end of the beach near 13th and Santa Lucia, the sandstone banks have been defaced by smoke and graffiti. And, he added, "instead of being swept out to sea in the winter and disappearing, the buoyant charcoal seems to return with the sand, dispersing all up and down the beach, even to the Ocean Avenue dunes area, where it appears to have caused areas of gray sand and widespread sections where the sand is heavily laced with charcoal bits of various sizes."

The city crew, ably overseen by Stu Ross of Public Works, has been working for over a month, at the south end of the beach, shoveling charcoal into large sifters, custom made for them by the CRA beach cleanup veterans Clayton Anderson and Wayne Kelley.

On one day in July, according to Stu Ross, the four workers, plus Ross, filled 65 large bags with charcoal -- which translates to nearly 3,000 pounds! And the job has just begun.

As much as we appreciate the city's efforts, it will be difficult to catch up with the old accumulated charcoal as well as to keep up with all the new fires built weekly and left to burn out in the sand. Also, the ash left behind after the cleanup of the fires themselves spreads out and defaces the sand. While we agree with Lloyd, who said he enjoys "a beach fire as much the next person," we also agree when he says that the situation has gotten out of control. We wonder how appropriate it actually is for the city and beach cleanup volunteers, on a permanent basis, to spend significant financial and physical resources cleaning up the fires of an ever-increasing number of beach users when even the cleanup cannot eliminate the soiling of the sand by the ashes.

Is it time for Carmel to think about restoring the luster of its crown jewel by banning all fires on the beach?

A start in this process would be to find out how residents actually feel about beach fires, after considering the above information. It would have been a good question for the city's General Plan survey.

President's Message
Carmel -- everybody's cup of tea

by Roberta Miller

While walking through Mission Trails Nature Preserve one day, in the early morning fog, I pondered the joy and sentiment that Carmel-by-the-Sea injects into my thoughts and being. This hideaway, small and serene, so close to large sprawling cities, has managed to set itself apart through the wonders of mother nature and our forefathers' vision. As embers of light spread through the trees, I smiled, resolving to enjoy each day and count my lucky stars. Maybe, just maybe, enjoying sentiment is almost as good as enjoying a cup of tea. I have tried to put some of these thoughts into the words below.

C harismatic, charming, cottage warmth, cultural mecca, chic nostalgia, canine cuties, coastline grandeur, communing with the natural environment, connoting a slower rhythm, capturing the imagination, community pride --
   
A lluring, an artistic haven, authentic, ambiance abounds, awakens the past, awe inspiring, atmospheric, attuned in harmony with nature, architectural diversity, arcane walkways and courtyards, aroma of wood smoke in the clear, crisp air --
   
R enowned for its natural resources, rustle of the wind and scent of pines, roads going around trees, reminiscent of times past, relaxing, room to roost, residential paradise, revitalizing the soul, romantic rendezvous, rambling weathered fences --
   
M emories made, meandering pathways, miles of recreational parkland and white sand beach, moonlit nights, magnificent sunsets, misty mornings, magical aura --
   
E nchanting, elegant, endearing, engaging, environmental harmony, eclectic shopping, element of surprise, easygoing life style, eccentric at times, emotional roller coaster, eye-popping natural beauty, enjoying the sun, sand and surf --
   
L ife's simple pleasures, loveable, lazy days, leisure walks on the beach, lingering in a courtyard cafe, laughing with friends, listening to the sound of birds in the forest, lofty trees, lifting your spirits, like no other place --

"Carmel-by-the-sea, by the sea, by the wonderful sea."



Council Watch

Here, as space allows, are a few highlights of City Council and other meetings since our last newsletter:

  • June -- Finalized a Memorandum of Understanding with the Carmel Firefighters Association giving firefighters an 8.75% salary increase.

  • June -- Allowed a Pine Inn project to continue through the planning process. It involves underground parking under 6th Ave. and First Murphy Park.

  • August -- Extended the ordinance allowing live music where liquor is sold for another three years.

  • August -- Contracted for the design and manufacture of a Saber PUC Pumper fire engine for $427,645.

  • August -- Awarded a $280,661 contract to Green Valley Landscaping for construction of the Fourth Avenue Riparian Habitat Restoration Project.

  • August -- Postponed naming Jeff Burghardt economic revitalization manager and approving Economic Revitalization Plan until the Sept. City Council meeting.

  • August -- Planning Commission voted to allow demolition of the Burde building (Homescapes) because the developer has planned two affordable housing units in the new Plaza Del Mar project. According to City Attorney Don Freeman, state affordable housing rules trump our code and general plan.

Del Mar Master Plan

A well-organized public workshop was held by the city on July 29 to brainstorm for the preparation of a master plan for Del Mar -- the sand dune area from 8th to the foot of Ocean Avenue, including the parking lot and the area behind and north of the rest rooms. City staff did an excellent job of eliciting suggestions from the audience.

The plan will address parking and circulation, pedestrian and disabled access, the aesthetics of the area and protection of environmental resources.

Among the priorities discussed -- restoration of native plants; protection of the fragile dunes habitat with designated paths or boardwalks; replanting of Monterey cypress where dead trees were removed; and making the sidewalks leading to the beach at Ocean Avenue more informal and visually pleasing.

There will be ample opportunity for public input when a draft plan is prepared.


October tree forum planned

Mark your calendar now for Thursday, Oct. 30, from 1 to 3:30 p.m., when the Friends of Carmel Forest and the Carmel Forest and Beach Commission will cosponsor a forum on trees at Sunset Center.

Watch the Oct. issue of CRA News for more details about the impressive keynote speaker and panelists.


Forum on the economics of heritage tourism

Did you know that heritage tourism is one of the fastest growing segments of tourism in the industry -- that visitors to historic sites and cultural attractions stay longer and spend more money than other kinds of tourists? When cities recapture their past, it pays off in more dollars!

The Alliance of Monterey Area Preservationists (AMAP) will present a forum on heritage tourism on Friday, Sept. 19, from 1 to 5 p.m. at the Monterey Maritime Museum.

Cosponsored by the City of Monterey and Pacific Grove Heritage, this stimulating afternoon will include nationally-recognized speakers as well as a lively panel discussion.

The cost is $50, or $40 for AMAP members. Send checks, payable to AMAP, to P.O. Box 2752, Monterey, CA, 93942.

For more information, call CRA member Anne Bell at 624-3942.


City Council asks for modifications
on Forest Theater plan

Carmel residents want their historic Forest Theater to retain its rustic charm. And, at a June 19 City Council workshop at the theater, they were gratified to hear that the council is moving in that direction in asking for a revised pre-design phase presentation from the architect.

An extensive plan prepared for the Forest Theater Foundation by a Los Angeles firm, R.F. McCann and Company Architects, became a cause for concern after it was presented at a May 20 City Council meeting.

The original plan includes a high masonry fence around the perimeter of the theater, a grass meadow to replace current parking, a larger seating footprint and increased building coverage with more height and more mass.

A 2001 Master Plan for the Forest Theater prepared by architect Brian Congleton stressed the rustic nature of the theater, striving to accommodate the real needs of theater users while minimizing stress on the forested site and the neighborhood by not increasing land coverage or expanding theater use.

The McCann plan, on the other hand, sets out a vision of a multi-million-dollar theater appropriate for professional equity actors, complete with "star" dressing rooms. CRA board member Richard Flower, in a statement to the City Council, suggested that the new plan has "one fatal flaw: The city failed to define what the theater should be. Should the Forest Theater be a rustic facility where local groups can perform for their local audiences? Or, should it be a venue which can accommodate major large-scale professional and semiprofessional productions? As presented, the plan seemed to assume the second option."

It became clear at the June 19 workshop that the City Council was united in wanting to pare down the project.

Among their recommendations were:

  • Retain a 6-foot double-sided grape-stake fence rather than the masonry wall. CRA board member and former Cultural Commission chairperson Carolyn Hardy wrote the council, "A character-defining element of a grape-stake fence is that you can see through the slats. I hope that this would still be possible with a double-sided fence that completely surrounds the theater property site. We want to carry on the tradition of peering through the fence!"

  • Leave the current parking inside the fence and on the street rather than excavating the perimeter of the property, causing the removal of significant trees.

  • Retain, but improve the existing concession stand, which was moved from Sunset Center at great expense, and add a ticket booth to it rather than erecting a new building.

  • Build the enlarged stage as shown in the plan but eliminate an excavated room under the seating. Hardy wrote, "In working toward a compromise of addressing the needs of the actors with reducing the scale of the structure, I hope you will consider asking Mr. McCann to strive to preserve as many existing trees around the structure as possible and configure backstage in a way that does not appreciably expand the footprint while providing the needed appropriate bathrooms, dressing areas and scene docks."

  • Maintain the existing seating footprint. In the proposed plan, the seating footprint was enlarged and more space was allocated per seat. Carolyn Hardy suggested that "such an expansion of use could create additional vehicular traffic at a time when the neighborhood is at a saturation point for parking cars."

After the workshop, Hardy praised the council saying, "You are definitely headed in the right direction to preserve and enhance our rustic community theater in its forested setting and I am encouraged by the changes you are making to the Foundation's ambitions plans. Thank you for your continued efforts."


Statewide Coastal Cleanup

Saturday, September 20
9 a.m. - noon

* Volunteers meet at foot of Ocean Avenue
* Please bring gloves
* Gene McFarland will be in charge.
* This takes the place of our regular monthly beach cleanup. Note that this is on the third Saturday, not the fourth Saturday



OLD CARMEL
by Connie Wright

Jimmy Hopper -- one of the Carmel gang

Jimmy Hopper was born James Marie Hopper of an Irish Fenian father and a petite French mother in 1876 in Paris. Bringing Jimmy and his twin brother John with her, she came to Oakland to teach music. She enrolled the boys in the Prescott School, the toughest school in Oakland, and sent them off wearing French velvet suits of the highly adorned style of 1887. The effect can be easily imagined: a fight ensued which Jimmy won, beating the toughest kid. He fought every day after that to maintain his reputation.

At eighteen he entered the University of California at Berkeley and took up football. At 5'6" and 142 pounds, he soon became the dynamic quarterback. Fans rose and screamed when he entered the field. While at Berkeley, he played a large part in the first-time stealing of the Stanford ax, a symbol of Stanford's power and ferocity.

Jimmy graduated from Berkeley, took a law degree at Hastings, and was admitted to the bar in 1900, but never practiced law. Instead he took a job at the Wave, a small San Francisco newspaper, at $10 a week. In 1901 he married Mattie Leonard. The next year they set off for the Philippines, where they started new schools and taught. Jimmy now began writing tales of the Philippines, which were ultimately published in McClures Magazine, one of the vital U.S. magazines of the time. Jimmy joined the McClures staff in San Francisco, where he was a regular at Coppa's, the meeting place for San Francisco Bohemians. When George Sterling introduced Mary Austin, then a rising literary star, to the group with a view to having her permanently join them, Jimmy pronounced that she was not pretty enough and was too outspoken. She herself described Jimmy as having "the face of a Breton sailor, and hair of one of Fra Angelico's angels."

Jimmy was working on the San Francisco Call when the 1906 San Francisco earthquake occurred. His account of the event appeared in Harper's Weekly and made him enough money "to enable me to give all my time to story writing." The place to do so, his friend George Sterling told him, was Carmel. Here they moved in 1907, but Jimmy was soon called by McClures to write a series on San Francisco graft trials. Jimmy met Fred Bechdolt in San Francisco and got him to come to Carmel. With a retired burglar as a source of information, Jimmy and Fred wrote 9009 (the informant's prison number), an exposé of prison conditions, which came out in the Saturday Evening Post in 1908. It was one of the Post's great serials and contributed to prison reform. In 1914, as World War I was breaking out, the Hoppers purchased George Sterling's house on Torres and 12th Street. Jimmy became the correspondent for Collier's, a leading liberal magazine, in France. At the end of the war, he returned to Carmel. In 1935 Mattie died, and in 1938 he married Elayne Lawson of Monterey.

In those latter days of his life, Jimmy could be seen sitting in his car, smoking one of his small, brown, French cigars, while Elayne shopped. Robinson Jeffers remembered him as the man who used to stand and talk at his garden sea gate, who loved the cold ocean and used to swim from Carmel Point to Point Lobos. Hopper's Rock off the Carmel Beach is named for him. He died in August, 1956 of a heart condition.

Altogether, Hopper published some three hundred short stories in addition to his newspaper work. He appears to have been the sweetest, kindest and most sensitive of the Carmel bunch.


Our Favorite Places

Brophy's Tavern

Mary and Bob Condry write, "Need a local spot for a great lunch, full dinner or just a tall cool one? We think Brophy's Tavern, on the N.E. corner of San Carlos and 4th, fills the bill. Owner Joe Cingari has maintained the sports bar concept, while serving really fine food and a variety of drinks at reasonable prices. Specials, such as the Friday night prime rib and taco night, are offered during the week.

"Stop by and see if Brophy's should become your 'local.' We're sure you'll be glad you did!"


Remember that your City Council is on T.V.

City Council meetings are taped and re-broadcast
Sundays, 8 a.m. - 12 noon on
KMST Channel 26

 


Carmel Residents Association
P.O. Box 13
Carmel, CA 93921
Phone: 831-626-1610
Contact the Carmel Residents Association
      Little house in Carmel