![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
CRA News October 2008Selected articles from the newsletter of the Carmel Residents Association
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
CRA October General Meeting:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Thursday, October 23 | |
| 4:45 p.m. Vista Lobos Meeting Room (Torres between 3rd & 4th) |
|
by Roberta Miller
Many years ago, while Monte and I were visiting
San Francisco, we went to see an exhibit at the San Francisco Museum of
Modern Art a showing of beautiful photographs of the "Painted Ladies"
of San Francisco. In the gift shop, we found a book entitled Painted
Ladies: San Francisco's Resplendent Victorians by Elizabeth Pomada
and Michael Larsen with lovely photographs by Morley Baer. The authors
described these old Victorians dating back to the 1850's and early 1900's
by saying "the facades crumbled with age, the powder cracked; the mascara
ran." The author went on to say that by the 1960's (remember that psychedelic
age), expression through color became the rage and people began painting
their houses with the colors of the day. By the mid 1970's these "Painted
Ladies" began to show their true colors and became the talk of the town.
With a map and book in hand, Monte and I knew this was going to be the
beginning of a lovely day. A quest to find as many of these beautiful
restored Victorian houses as our feet would allow.
I did not know Enid Sales then, nor her contributions to the renaissance
of the "Painted Ladies," by saving over 350 of them. Nor the story of
her trucking, in the middle of the night, 13 Victorian houses across town
to a new location, as part of San Francisco's residential rehabilitation
program. But, that was soon to change.
With the passing of Enid, I was reminded of this memorable day in San
Francisco, and wondered if Enid, at least in terms of spirit, just might
be Carmel's Painted Lady. She saw life in great buildings that invited
you in, evoked visions of other times, stirred your love of beauty and
sense of connection with past lifestyles. I think that within these buildings
her humanity found a home.
Enid was a woman of substance. An extraordinary woman. She cut a colorful
swath. The first woman in the state to pass the test for a contractor's
license, a well-known preservationist and advocate, who helped characterize
and shape the modern movement for historic preservation. Her career spanned
more than 50 years. She was hard working, courageous, controversial, authentic,
mysterious, independent, determined, resolute, tenacious, a cut above,
a force to be reckoned with and never took her eye off the prize
the need to preserve the historic buildings of the
past for future generations to enjoy and appreciate as part of their collective
heritage.
The saying, "actions speak louder than words," certainly applied to Enid
Sales. In Carmel, Enid was known for her fierce advocacy for the preservation
of arts and crafts cottages and her willingness to resort to lawsuits
when all else failed. A warrior, ready to do battle and steadfast in her
resolve.
The First Murphy House, slated for demolition, was saved by Enid, rescuing
it from its original Mission Street location with another flatbed truck.
She fought to save the Flanders Mansion by placing it on the National
Register of Historic Places.
When the Door House, a cottage constructed entirely of old doors, was
about to be demolished, Enid had it temporarily moved and ultimately found
a home for it on the property of Karyl Hall and her late husband Fred
Nelson.
She also placed Sunset Center on the National Register and successfully
advocated against demolishing the building. Her efforts were instrumental
in creating the stunningly-restored building we enjoy today.
Enid was the founder of the Carmel Preservation Foundation, which over
the years has worked diligently for city policies to protect Carmel's
history. She was honored as Preservationist of the Year in 2006 by the
California Preservation Society.
And, in 1990, Enid was named Citizen of the Year by the Carmel Residents
Association.
The Herald's Rants & Raves column recently said, "Enid Sales
was the opposite of a one-woman wrecking crew. She was a one-woman preservation
crew, saving enough historic structures from Carmel to San Francisco to
qualify herself as a national historic monument. Others, plural, will
be needed to carry on her work."
Carry on we must. There is unfinished business, Enid's unfinished business.
She was vocal in wanting to save the architectural integrity of the Burde
bank building and keep it from being demolished. She wanted to rescue
the Scout House from "demolition by neglect," restore it and give it back
to the public. She envisioned Carmel having a Historic Downtown District.
She always had another project in mind, waiting for her to roll up her
sleeves and lead the charge. Like those "Painted Ladies" in San Francisco,
Enid has left a lasting legacy.
Now, the torch has been passed to those who remain. We are the keepers
of the flame. Who will answer the challenge? Mary Austin said, "It is
not I that belong to the past, but the past that belongs to me."
Former City Council member and Carmel
Residents Association board member Barbara Livingston has filed an appeal
of the Planning Commission's approval of the demolition of the Burde
building, on the corner of Dolores and 7th. In addition to her personal
passion to preserve this building, Livingston told CRA News,
"We are finishing Enid Sales' unfinished business!" (See President's
Message.)
Because City Attorney Don Freeman told Planning Commissioners that state
affordable housing rules trump our code and general plan, they felt
they had no other recourse than approval of the demolition since the
developer has planned two affordable housing units in his proposed Plaza
Del Mar project.
The appeal will be heard at the City Council's Nov. 4 meeting.
It contends that the same code which grants incentives and concessions
to developers to contribute to the production of low-income housing,
says that local governments do not have to waive or reduce development
standards if the waiver or reduction would have a specific, adverse
impact upon the physical environment, which cannot be mitigated. And,
there is no adequate mitigation for the removal of this significant
building. We agree.
Joining in this appeal are the Monterey Chapter of the American Institute
of Architects and the Alliance of Monterey Bay Area Preservationists.
The CRA Board has long spoken out in favor of saving this building,
built in 1972 by the notable architect Walter Burde. In 2006 Roberta
Miller, speaking for the board, said to the City Council, "When faced
with the choice of saving a magnificent building created by a noteworthy,
award-winning architect versus demolishing and replacing it with a complex,
similar to the hundreds of structures being designed these days, we
think the answer is an easy one ... Vote for Carmel's architectural
diversity; vote for Carmel's important recent history." The board is
also concerned about the increased traffic congestion the proposed project
would create.
Olof Dahlstrand, resident, architect, former City Councilman, Planning
Commission chair and Carmel Residents Association Citizen of the Year,
told the City Council, "This building is widely recognized in the design
profession as an exceptionally fine piece of architecture and an important
element in not only Carmel's character, but also that of the entire
Monterey Peninsula. Its loss would result in another slip into our becoming
more like Anytown U.S.A."
Other notable local buildings by Walter Burde are the award-winning
Carmel Shell Station, San Carlos and 5th, and the Carmel Christian Science
Church, Monte Verde near 6th.
You are invited by the Carmel Celebrates
Community Committee to the city's 92nd birthday on Saturday, Oct. 25.
The parade begins at 11 a.m., winding its way down and back up Ocean
Avenue, ending at Sunset Center, where a delicious lunch will be served
at noon. For the bargain price of $5 per person, participants will enjoy
a hot dog, chili, chips, soda and birthday cake.
Tickets can be purchased at City Hall or at Nielsen Bros Market on the
corner of San Carlos and 7th.
Entertainment will be provided by the Carmel Rotary Blues Band.
For more information, call 620-2000.
Thanks to CRA Board member Casey
MacKenzie for tabulating the surveys.
Out of 71 responses, 33 (46%) wanted to ban all fires; 10 (14%) wanted
fires only in contained grills; and 28 (39%) were happy with the current
ban on fires N. of 10th Ave.
Adding those in favor of a total ban and those wanting only contained
grills, 60% of the respondents wanted some action taken to protect
the beach.
Here are some representative examples of the comments we received:
Saturday, October 18
(Third Saturday because of city birthday)
10 a.m. - noon
* Volunteers
meet at foot of Ocean Avenue
* Please bring gloves
* Coffee and cookies served courtesy of Caffe Cardinale and Safeway
Stores, Carmel.
* Thanks to the Pine Cone for the ad donated each month!
An enlightening Tree Forum will
take place from 2 to 4:30 p.m. on Thursday, Oct. 30, in Sunset Center's
Carpenter Hall. Co-sponsored by Friends of Carmel Forest and the Carmel
Forest and Beach Commission, the event started in 2006 as a way to provide
information and foster discussion on issues related to living within
Carmel's native forest. Admission is free and complimentary parking
is available at Sunset Center's San Carlos and 10th Avenue lots.
The goal of the Tree Forum is to educate the public on the economic
value of the Carmel forest. Known worldwide for its exceptional beauty
and unique ecosystem, the Carmel forest faces challenges including an
aging tree population, development impacts and disease.
The keynote address, Money Does Grow on Trees: The Economic Benefits
of Trees to Property Owner, will be given by Kelaine Vargas,
urban ecologist at the U.S. Forest Service's Center for Urban Forest
Research at U.C. Davis.
A panel discussion will follow including Kelly Quirke, former
executive director of San Francisco's Friends of the Urban Forest; Sharon
Kelly, program director for Canopy in Palo Alto; and Brian Kempf,
director of the Urban Tree Foundation in Visalia.
For more information, please visit the Friends of Carmel Forest website
at www.carmelforest.org
The CRA "Fiesta in the Forest,"
held on August 21, was a fantastic event again this year. How nice to
have warm weather for our picnic at Indian Village! All the CRAers who
attended were happy to gather again to greet each other and enjoy the
homemade picnic dinner.
Most of you who attend help out in making the fiesta possible. Thanks
to all of you volunteers! We are always especially grateful to the cooks
who make our Mexican rice
this year they were Vi Fox, Jean Grace, Helen Jaye, Casey
MacKenzie and Dianne Terrell.
There are two guys named Tony who were indispensable volunteer workers
Tony Diamond,
as well as Jane Diamond, were co-planners of the barbecue. Tony Budlong
is the amazing "Juan-of-all-trades" and does shopping, cooking, serving
and steps in wherever needed.
Many were first-time volunteers, including Mike and Mary Ellen Wilson,
who were enthusiastic helpers since the planning began. Thanks also
to Chuck and Vi Fox, Tom and Chris Gaspich, Ovilee Kennedy, Jim and
Beth Wright and Larry and Joan Zaslow, who pitched in as "first-timers."
Special thanks to Dorothy Cole, who hand painted the festive name tags
and to Gloria Eldred, who has made salad for many years as well as coordinating
the signage and balloons to guide us on the road to Indian Village.
¡Gracias a todos! Thanks to everyone who helped with the BBQ!
[Everyone who attended joins the CRA Board in thanking Susie and
Don Carr and Jane and Tony Diamond, whose hard work made this another
successful fiesta!]
by Tom Parks
Ars Gratia Artis
Eleen Auvil is a tiny lady working
large. It's not the least unusual to find sculptures reaching eight or
ten feet in her studios. She works in bronze, often with a blow torch
in one hand and a hankie in another. She admits that the making of art
is her life's work. Still, she finds time to cook, garden, sit as president
of the board of directors of the Carl Cherry Foundation, serve whatever
needs to be served at CRA events, travel, read and be a good friend to
countless residents of this village. Her output is prodigious.
Whether installing a four hundred pound bronze tree with sitting birds
or a delicate pastiche made of Carmel beach sand, weeds and paper, Ms.
Auvil makes her distinctive statement.
Busy all the time, she agreed to give us an hour recently to ask a few
questions. Once she had put aside the blow torch, we settled down with
a glass of sherry.
When did you come to Carmel and from where?
I moved to Monterey County in 1975 and settled in the hills of Corral
de Tierra where I built a house and a large studio. In 2002 I built another
house and studio in Carmel where I live now.
You're a well respected artist. Is Carmel conducive to the making of
art?
It is, of course who wouldn't be happy to make art here. Actually,
I do what I call my 'clean work' paper, clay in the studio
at my house, and the 'dirty work' bronze at my second studio
in Sand City, a wonderful refuge for artists of all bents.
In what mediums do you work?
I work in several mediums, as I've said: bronze and wax, handmade paper,
stone, oil ...
You support this community. What are your interests outside your own
work?
I do a great deal of reading on all subjects. And I love gardening. I
find myself in the garden when I'm satisfied with my work output; when
I seek the peace of the soil.
Known for Bohemians of the past, do you believe that Carmel remains
a center of culture and artistic excellence?
I think that's a highly romantic take on this village. The truth is most
serious artists can't afford to live here. Or even on the Peninsula for
that matter.
Would you care to comment on the existence of 120 art galleries in
this little village of under 5,000 people?
(A chuckle) That's about one gallery for every 40 citizens. And if you
deduct the second home, sometime residents, that's one for every 20 residents.
Anyway, the vast majority of galleries are not devoted to Carmel artists.
What is your feeling concerning public art? How is it chosen? Who are
the arbiters? Is this art by committee?
Sadly, the Arts Commission was disbanded sometime ago.
Art by committee is always risky. That's when art becomes political in
the sense of what is good, respectable, imaginative, even profound. I
haven't seen anything of the sort in the public places in this village.
What about city government? Are you satisfied with our elected officials?
Are they, in your opinion, doing the jobs they were elected to do?
They are doing the jobs they were elected to do.
What strictly Carmel issues interest you the most the beach,
the forest, the arts?
The arts, of course. And the beauty of the beach and the forest and the
parks. Mission Trail has been so improved lately.
The Flanders Mansion is vacant. It can't be sold. It's an asset to
some, a burden to others. Any ideas for its future use?
What a wonderful museum, for local art owned by the city, the Flanders
would make. With special exhibits by serious Peninsula artists. There
are many of them. This does not mean that the Carmel Art Association is
not first class. It seems to me there would be no conflict with the existence
of a Carmel Museum of Art.
How would you best describe the experience of living and making art
in Carmel-by-the-Sea?
A wonderful experience. I feel I belong here.
[Eleen's art can be seen at the Carmel Art Association (inside, as
well as three sculptures in the garden), in the sculpture garden of the
Cherry Center and at Hauk Fine Art in Pacific Grove.]
Tom Parks, a Carmel Residents Association board member, is a well-known
writer of fiction, essays, book reviews and plays. Over the last ten years,
he has produced a number of musicals and plays locally. He is currently
working on a novel and a new play, What Fresh Hell Is This? The Wit
and Wisdom of Dorothy Parker, for a spring, 2009 opening at the Carl
Cherry Center.
Jack London was born in San Francisco
in 1876. Evidently illegitimate, he was raised along the Oakland waterfront,
and attended school only through the eighth grade. As a teenager, he and
his gang raided oyster beds about the Bay. In 1893 he went to Japan on
a sealing cruise, then on a tramping trip through the U.S. and Canada,
followed by one semester at Berkeley. He returned to the Oakland waterfront
with an interest in sociology and the Socialist Party. He read Spencer,
Darwin, Marx and Nietzsche. When he met George Sterling in 1901 at a picnic,
Jack was seven years younger than George but more sophisticated and experienced
and a successful writer.
George and Jack soon became best friends, addressing each other as "Wolf"
(London) and "Greek" (Sterling), because of his Grecian profile. George
found a house for Jack near his own in Piedmont. They made the San Francisco
Bohemian scene, trolling after women. On one occasion, they ended the
evening fighting with tong members for the favors of a sing-song girl
in Chinatown. Their wives were furious.
Jack always wrote 1,000 words a day. He published The Call of the Wild
in 1903 and The Sea Wolf in 1904, which were great successes. He
made a lot of money from his writing, had a Japanese valet, drank Martinis
and ate fine beef or rare duck, while the Carmel gang ate mussels and
abalone and drank cheap Muscatel.
Jack and his second wife Charmian visited George and Carrie Sterling in
Carmel in 1906 while Jack was building The Snark, a fifty-foot ketch on
which they planned at least seven years at sea. On Jack's first visit
to Carmel, Arnold Genthe, the professional photographer, noted, "Jack
London had a poignantly sensitive face. His eyes were those of a dreamer,
and there was almost a feminine wistfulness about him. Yet at the same
time he gave the feeling of a terrific and unconquerable force." The Carmel
gang turned out for the occasion and they swam, hiked, ran and dived for
abalone, and talked, and talked and talked. Jack believed that an occasional
love affair was necessary for the creative artist, but Mary Austin vehemently
disagreed. She later asserted: "Women flung themselves at Jack, lay in
wait for him."
The Snark, an unreliable tub, set sail in December, 1906, with six people
aboard and the Carmel gang in attendance at the Oakland wharf. Jack and
Charmian returned in July, 1909, without The Snark or her crew. Seems
the crew, who hated the boat, bailed out in Hawaii and the Londons abandoned
the craft in the Marquesas Islands.
George wanted Jack to move to Carmel, but Jack was busy building his baronial
mansion, the Wolf House, in Glen Ellen, where he wanted to breed cattle.
Jack and Charmian visited George and Carrie a second time in 1910. This
time Jack was quite subdued and the physical games gave way to bridge,
which George, Jack and friends played almost interminably for the Londons'
ten-day stay.
The unfinished Wolf House burned down. Jack had gotten heavy, was drinking
a lot, became increasingly hypochondriacal, and said that he hated writing.
He died in 1916 either of kidney failure (Charmian's version) or by taking
a cyanide pill (Elsie Martinez' and others' version).
The following information comes
from CRA board member Richard Flower, who follows library issues.
While public libraries all over the United States have faced closure
or, at least, suffered serious reductions in open hours and available
services, Carmel's Harrison Memorial Library continues to operate
as a reasonably healthy institution. This situation results from a
unique arrangement, unknown to many. The City of Carmel pays for core
library staff and for building maintenance. All books and other materials
and many other essentials are covered by grants from the Carmel Public
Library Foundation, which is entirely supported by voluntary contributions
from generous public-spirited individuals.
This year an unfortunate, but probably inevitable, situation has occurred.
Because of declining investment income, the Board of Directors of
the Foundation found it necessary to reduce its contribution to next
year's library budget by $60,000. To accommodate this reduction, the
library staff must now eliminate or curtail important programs in
such areas as youth services.
To insure that this situation is only temporary, the board of the
Foundation has pledged to intensify its fund raising efforts. As an
expression of its ongoing appreciation of the Foundation's enrichment
of the lives of the residents of our village, the Carmel Residents
Association encourages its members, who are already Library Foundation
contributors, to increase their contributions this year. Members who
have not previously contributed are urged to include the Foundation
as a beneficiary of their end-of-year giving. The Foundation's address
is Carmel Public Library Foundation, P.O. Box 2042, Carmel 93921.
Cindi Mitchell, the city's animal control officer, has been handing out a delightful brochure published by the Police Department listing Carmel-by-the-Sea dog ordinances. Here are some of the rules:
City Council meetings are taped
and re-broadcast
Sundays, 8 a.m. - 12 noon on
KMST Channel 26
|
![]() |