Carmel-by-the-Sea Parking Dilema(s)

Paid Parking, once again, has made the City Council priority List in our Village (FY 2022/2023).  As of this writing, this project will include significant community input and new technologies in the possibilities. We will continue to update this page as this new City project gets underway.   (An expanding list of online articles from the past are at the bottom of this web page)

Carmel has had at least 2 prior attempts at a Paid Parking that were withdrawn largely due to community objections.  At least one of these initiatives, was likely to meet or exceed its goals, but for not.  Visit this page again, for future links to articles on those prior efforts. 

 

       From a prior/past Village Paid Parking Project        Challenges of Carmel Parking? (an online game)

There are many benefits of paid parking, revenue being a big one with the contributions it could make to our city income.  Another can/could be improved access to open parking space - especially given what new mobile technology can bring to the deployment. 

Stepping back, there is no question that parking can be a challenge in our town, especially during larger local events, and also routinely when visitors escape the heat to our cooler coastal climate. Is paid parking "the" answer?  It could be. 

As a part of educating our community on this new project, consider this YouTube and expert Book author on the "High Cost of Free Parking" Professor Shoup. Dr. Shoup clarifies the costs of cars hunting for spaces, the actual cost of the space and much more.

In-depth Dr. Shoup Interview YouTube here (Sept 2021)
Wikipedia on Professor Shoup here
Freakonomics Podcast here (Mar 2013)


On the other side and with much longer term planning considerations could be making our downtown "Car Free" or better said "Pedestrian Only".  This aligns with increasing quantities of European towns and this option could make a contribution to decreasing greenhouse gases.  There are many sources online that speak to the benefits of going Car Free.  Here are just a few.

Wikipedia on CarFree Cities here
CNN Video interview of Janette Sadik-Khan here (8/28/2022)
The Atlantic article (April 2021) here

Your additions, comments and suggestions are very welcome in the months to come. 


Online articles on Paid (Metered) Parking efforts over time in our Village, for more background.  

  • April 2021 - Monterey Herald - Carmel elected officials consider paid parking — again HERE
  • December 2014 - KSBW Camel parking meters up and running on Ocean Avenue HERE
  • December 2014 - Carmel Pine Cone - Cover "Metered Parking to go live Dec 1"  HERE
  • October 2014 -  CedarStreet Times - Carmel will hold a public workshop on Ocean Ave. pilot parking project.  HERE
  • November 2013 - Carmel-by-the-Sea Watchdog - Downtown Parking Analysis and Parking Recommendations – Draft HERE
  • January 2011 - Carmel-by-the-Sea Watchdog - BACKGROUND: Downtown Paid Parking Program (2000-2002) HERE